New Kitchen Rugs

To several years I've had two of these rugs in my kitchen, one by the sink and one by the prep area.  But now I think they looked a little tired and the design just doesn't do it for me anymore.

While I was at Target the other day, I spied these cute little rugs for $15 and snatched two up.  What do you think?  It's smaller (2'-x-3') than the old rug.  I'm not sold yet...

And then there's always this one from Ikea...